Place chicken breasts into crock pot. I clarified the instructions- first cook with the soup (or broth), then add in the filler and seasonings. The Kewpee was, and still is, famous for: square hamburgers, frosted chocolate malted, and chili but no fries for many years. Your email address will not be published. Toss to coat and set aside. A true family favorite! I bet that Chicken Rice Soup is divine! I just wanted to comment on the use of canned chicken. Cover and cook on low for 3-4 hours. Yes, perfect for cool/cold days. That is a basic timeline. Thanks for the memories, everyone. We still have her stained recipe card. Now I can make them and will enjoy. GO BENGALS! They started with chickens that would be cooked down until the meat fell apart. **We are not dietitians and recommend you seek a nutritionist for exact nutritional information. Definitely my favorite sandwich. INN THE PINES made theirs with baked chicken and gravy, mashed potatoes on the side, and freshly-made hot waffles with homemade ice cream for dessert (ever had a waffle ice-cream sandwich??) Theyre served at all the drive-in restaurants, and at every pot luck (my favorite comes from Jollys Root Beer Stand, served with a bag of Ballreichs Potato Chips!). It's a healthy addition to soups, salads, pasta, tacos, wraps or sandwiches. Cover and cook on HIGH for 6 hours or until cooked through. INGREDIENTS 28 ounces (1 can) 1 can of Gerber's Fully Cooked CANNED CHICKEN 1 can cream of mushroom soup 1/2 cup seasoned bread crumbs To taste celery salt To taste pepper 1/4 tsp. The only thing that made it tolerable was knowing Id get a shredded chicken sandwich from the concession trailer at lunch time. Loved these too! Cover and cook until stuffing and crumbs are soft, about 30 minutes. Noodles and mashed potatoes. Then the next year they say, I hope you made those noodles. Ohio lives on in so many memories and the food we eat. They were so good! Its simple comfort food and Ill be doing it this Christmas and New Years. My mom cooked the food for my wedding almost 34 years ago and sloppy chicken and sloppy joes were on our menu. ? In a bowl, mix together the remaining ingredients. Im hosting my family reunion this Sunday. Isnt there just something about that combination that makes life just a little sweeter? I remember my sisters and I watching Patches and Pockets! It is often served as a sandwich filling or as a side dish. Remember taking my Great Grandma (Ole Granny) to ice cream socials. Shelly- thanks so much for stopping by to comment. We always have made it with the cream soupmushroom or chicken and stove top stuffing breadcrumb mix. Judy Ault Billings. Thanks for stopping by to comment. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. You will find them being served at all kinds of gatherings, from parties to potlucks and they are sold at most local ice cream shops. I love shredded chicken recipes. Butter the bread, trim the crusts. Before downloading Amish Shredded Chicken Sandwiches Videos, The world largest online music service. How to make shredded chicken sandwiches Combine: Mix together cream of chicken soup, chicken broth, poultry seasoning, garlic powder, salt, and pepper in a slow cooker. Served them at the firehouse!! It really is great family, comfort food. To me all you taste is stuffing. You can add a bit more of lemon juice if you like along with little olive oil. Hope that helps. I am from Fostoria, OH- Seneca Co. My family loves Chicken wings with Blue Cheese dressing to dip them in! Pour the condensed soup overtop. Great memories of the Buckeye State. . This recipe sounds delicious.is it possible to make it with chicken thighs? WOW! But I wanted to introduce you to this family fave. Place chicken breasts in 2.5-4 quart crockpot. Gonna try it! Store any leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. That would make sense with the limited ingredients in them as people had access to limited items. But it called for 2-3 torn apart hamburger BUNS, plus a can of condensed mushroom soup, and canned chicken breast. Required fields are marked *. Mold up the edges slightly. Grew up with these at home and at Stewarts root beer. Learn how your comment data is processed. These were everywhere up on the lake, Port Clinton, Sandusky, Huron. Add turkey and butter/veggie mixture, and gently toss to mix. Any recommendations on some good sides to accompany the sandwiches? My father-in-law, who was a meat and potatos guy, always liked when I fixed this for football Saturdays, or any night for quick and easy meals. Stir to mix with sauce. Being a player, we werent able to get them during the game; however, the moms would always deliver us a huge box of leftover sandwiches after the game! Unless you grew up in Ohio, you cant understand how much a part of your life these sandwiches really were. I am from Perrysburg, now living in Texas. Below you will see my version of this Buckeye State classic recipe (with a few twists to give it a bit more oomph). I too am from Columbus and im wondering if pork rinds could be used instead of chips/stuffing. In Central Ohio, we only use Ritz crackers (about 30) for the filler. The chips Ive heard are no longer available and/or were changed. (to thin only if the mixture seems to thick), The calories shown are based on the recipe serving 10, with 1 serving being 1/10 of the chicken (no bun). Instead of stuffing: Italian breadcrumbs, crushed potato chips. Now to find Ballreichs in SC. I crush a sleeve of buttery townhouse crackers add that to the chicken, add cream of chicken soup and a teaspoon of poultry seasoning. Leftovers mixed with cooked noodles make a great casserole. Im from the south and had never heard of this. How to Make Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches Place the chicken breasts in the slow cooker. Thanks for sharing! This classic Keystone shredded chicken sandwich is sure to please even the pickiest of eaters in the family. If needed, thin mixture out with chicken broth. My grandmothers recipe used oatmeal too. Saltines are too salty and taste like flour. I did the same thing. Chicken combined with creamy soup and crushed crackers or potato chips come together to make one tasty sandwich. Some in Ohio have never heard of them, but others eat them at every potluck. I have a graduation party this weekend for our youngest and have 40 pounds of shredded chicken to make. (Notice: you will not be adding water or milk with the cream of chicken soup.) Do you know how many cups of chicken youd typically get from 3-4 chicken breasts? When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. How long is a few hours too cook the chicken before shredding? I was at a loss of what to make. Youre welcome, Youre welcome, Youre welcome! Overall, like Chipped Beef on Toast, this meal is all about memories, nostalgia and regional tradition. They safeguard their recipes and would never tell me the recipe. Think Ill try french fried onions. Other side ideas are baked beans, coleslaw, homemade potato salad, or mac and cheese. Stir it and off. 3 boneless skinless chicken breasts 1 can cream of chicken soup can substitute can of chicken broth - just add a little more breadcrumbs 1-1 1/2 C seasoned breadcrumbs, saltine crackers, croutons or mix dash of seasoned salt and garlic powder to taste Instructions Cook chicken breast with chicken soup in crockpot for a few hours on low. Hi -I grew up in Perrysburg then moved to Port Clinton. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Add to the salad ingredients and gently stir them until the ingredients are well combined. Growing up in Ohio, it seemed that every event; whether it be a graduation, a church potluck, a carry in dinner, family reunion, baseball game, school events, or even the fair, you would find this creamy and delicious sandwich. And there are countless ways to make them! Season with salt and pepper to taste. Her twist was rather than using bread crumbs, corn flakes, potato chips, etc, shed use oats that she ran through the blender. Add cream of chicken soup, chicken broth, poultry seasoning, garlic powder, salt, and pepper to slow cooker. ** Nutrient information is not available for all ingredients. The one referenced in the story preceding the recipe is not just canned chicken, it is a chicken in a can. Before you are ready to serve, add in the remaining ingredients and let everything cook together for 10 15 minutes. I hope I can make the same as what Ohio offers. You are very welcome! Thanks for sharing! YES KW! If you have large chicken breasts (10 oz), add 1-2 minutes onto the cook time. The best Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches! Remember: Carolina BBQ is not the same as other regional BBQ sauces, so know what you're getting when making this recipe. Elizabeth Hall. Add and stir in the chicken broth as needed if mixture becomes a little dry. Using a fork or your fingers, shred the chicken. Making for Superbowl.go Falcons!! I never get tired of hearing the stories with this recipe! Stir to combine. We arr actually on our way to Tiffin, Ohio right now for a small family reunion and planning to stock up on a supply of Ballreights , Ive lived on the lake 30 miles west of Cleveland in Amherst my whole 63 yrs and never heard of this. Easy Rotisserie Pulled Chicken Sandwich - Kinders . I make mine with thighs because they shred better. Spent my childhood in the 60s-70s being dragged around to auctions by my mom. 2 LG can of cooked chicken (48oz each) 3 cans of cream of chicken (10 1/2oz each) and Ritz crackers for the buttery flavor that is very distinct. It freezes well too! Grease a 12-inch pizza pan. I did mine with 1/2 chips (cause I had crumbs in the bottom of the bag!) Potato chips and chicken on a sandwich?? Its totally up to your preference. We lived in Findlay. Especially Thanksgiving! Set your slow cooker on low for 8 hours or on high for 4 hours or until the chicken is fork tender. Hello fellow transplanted buckeye! There were loads of innovations at our drive-ins .. Fast "Fried Chicken" before Colonel Sanders ever ventured north. Shredded Turkey Sandwiches are great for an easy dinner, too! Want to make these sandwiches for Christmas Eve. I would imagine you could though. I would actually just recommend leaving out the chips. Place 1 cup of the chicken mixture on the bottom of a bun, top with 4 dill pickle slices and place top bun half on top. Excited to try this recipe this weekend. If you are from Ohio, you might be familiar with these shredded chicken sandwiches. There was a meal at the church afterward with so much delicious food, including a big pile of buns and a big dish of the chicken mix. If you are using leftover chicken, do this same process. Yay! Level: . You are right with that, but have you tried Ballreich chips? In a slow cooker combine the chicken, cream cheese, and Ranch seasoning. Connie- PRIVACY POLICY. Add the melted butter, flour, baking powder, sugar, and salt to the egg and milk. I too am from NW Ohio, Bluffton to be exact and loved the chicken sandwiches from the local DQ. Im originally from Tiffin, Ohio, in Seneca County, where the shredded chicken sandwich remains a staple. Homemade is delicious and much healthier than using canned soup especially if you are watching salt content. Each can of chicken will make about 16 to 20 sandwiches. I use to be Patches on the Patches and Pockets show so traveled all over Ohio..Thanks. My uncle had a deli Ohio. Tap the stars to rate or give a rating the comments section below. I sure do miss home. The FDA recommends chicken be cooked to an internal temperature of 165 degrees Fahrenheit. You may need to add a little more of your crackers/chips/breadcrumbs when you thaw it because it might get a little watered down. Maybe another reader can chime in on their experience. My aunts used the whole chicken if they couldnt get their hands on the canned chicken. Thank you for posting this. I too am from Findlay and just stocked up on my last trip home. I love Shredded Chicken Sandwiches. Stir soup and water into the pot. Shred chicken with two forks and place back into crock pot. Right before I left, my aunt gave me a can of Brinkmans chicken to try & make it. On a floured surface, roll dough into a 13-inch circle. Although I think my husband would revolt if I used canned meat (he say he can taste the difference) I also use any leftovers to make creamy chicken soup with it. Usually about a sleeve from the box of Ritz will do it, sometimes more - sometimes less. As well as all the fairs, ice cream socials, etc. I live in Indiana now; but grew up in Ohio. A crockpot full of this stuff is a huge hit here every time! Im frugal, but yikes I wouldnt want to bite into the skin either! Maxies is gone so now the spot is Woodys for their shredded chicken sandwich. I too had no idea that this was an Ohio dish. Then if you want it a little thinner, add in the broth and/or water. Afterward I deboned, de-tendoned, and deskinned the the bird and put all that mess back into the pressure-cooker and covered it with the stock it was cooked in previously. Its been in the teens up here. In a medium bowl, mix all together. in Education and over 30 years of cooking and baking, I want to teach YOU the best of our family recipes. With 3 kids under the age of 4, I didnt have a lot of time, so throwing chicken breasts, cream of chicken soup and stuffing in a slow cooker was my go-to. You can cook it in a can of cream of chicken soup or broth. I have everything I need! Thank you for posting this recipe!! I followed your recipe cooking in just chicken broth, seasoned salt and garlic powder. I am a buckeye and remember this sandwich at the concession stand at every football game. Nothing but shredded chicken sandwiches and cracklins say Ohio more to me. Love these sandwiches and grew up eating them in the buckeye state. And I love all the comments too! You just made my DEY! I did add chicken broth to the recipe as the soup was not enough. These ingredients are used as a filler and to add a little bulk to the mixture. Was raised in Newark, OH. More chicken and less fillers.I My Mom and sister also made it this way. Nashville Hot Chicken and Waffle Sandwich, Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Sandwiches, Hot Buffalo Chicken, Bacon, and Cheese Sandwich. Cf Wendys. Bring to a boil, then reduce to medium heat. I love to hear everyones stories on this recipe! When the chicken is tender, transfer to a board and shred with two forks. And OATMEAL? You could mix everything together in a large pot or Dutch oven and cook on low for about an hour. Thank you! Over time the sandwich has changed with slow cooking or pressure cooking (my preferred method) the chicken and then adding soup. Total Time 30 Minutes Serving Size 6 Servings Ingredients Directions Recipe Nutrition Information - Per Serving Made With TAGS American Main Dish Sandwiches 300 Calories or Less Lisa- Thanks for that question. In addition to these sandwiches, you would also find a bag or box of Ballreich. My sister, who lives in Ohio, often makes the pulled chicken for family gatherings. I am a IL transplant from NW Ohio, Defiance Co. No one makes pulled chicken sandwiches around here! Continue making according to recipe. Usually add the cream of chicken soup and also some chicken stock / base. Step 3: Heat until everything is thoroughly heated. Serve immediately. Seasonings Poultry seasoning, garlic powder, salt and pepper. We always used canned Keystone Meats chicken (made in LIma) or Sweet Sue, one can of cream of chicken soup, one sleeve (or more) of Town House crackers, and season with some poultry seasoning and black pepper. It's such an easy way to cook chicken breasts. Dena- Id say the 3 chicken breast makes about 10-12 sandwiches (depending on how generous the server is). My future son in law loves this!!! From what I understand, shredded chicken sandwiches are a very regional dish. Was not disappointed SOOOO good and cheap! Thanks for sharing! Required fields are marked *. . Pour over chicken and give a quick stir to combine. Thank you!! Add cup or so of broth, salt and pepper and simmer until chicken is really tender. Ive become a Mike-Sells girl. One of the easiest and best comfort foods. Required fields are marked *. So good. Let shredded chicken cook soak in the sauce on the keep warm function for at least 1 hour before serving. Different families have their own version. Thanks for commenting! It is seasoned with salt, pepper, and other herbs and spices, giving it a flavorful and creamy texture. Cook on low for 6-8 hours or on high for 4 hours, until chicken shreds easily. It brings back memories of playing softball and family reunions. Got the recipe from my sister-in-law.shes from Barnesville, Ohio. Nice to bring a recipe from my childhood in Ohio to Colorado. CHOW CHOW: Ah, nothing like an end-of-summer chow chow. Thanks for commenting Brandi. That sounds delicious! Everyone keeps mentioning the chips- I think I have to try that one next time too! That sandwich looks like a real favorite of anyone who loves chicken and sandwiches. For this recipe, is the cream of chicken the 10.5oz can? Im using Turkey for mine and also use stuffing mix. I grew home in Fremont, Ohio home of Roots Shredded Chicken. Im originally from Tiffin, OH and my mom made (what we called) sloppy chicken sandwiches quite often as a way to usr leftover chicken. Shred with fork or chop into small pieces. Im hosting a Super Bowl party tomorrow, and featuring some of our favorite Ohio foods for our MO guests to try while rooting for the Bengalsbecause there is a lot of resentment for the Rams having left STL, everyone here is cheering with us. Serve on good quality buns. You will need 1 1/2 cups of your favorite filler. Difference being if we didnt use Sweet Sue we stewed a whole chicken, not just the breast. Good to be home. No preservatives used. Thanks for stopping by to leave your comments! So whos up for a meet-n-greet down here with some shredded chicken sandwiches and sloppy joes? Chicken Broth Use a little broth to help thin out the mixture. How about turning them into another comfort food recipe? A real Buckeye recipe! I grew up near Zanesville and remember these from church potlucks and family get-togethers. Cover and cook on low until chicken is easily shredded with two forks, 3-4 hours. Im glad you enjoyed the recipe! Combine all ingredients, and heat on the stove or in a slow cooker until well warmed. (I live in Florida now, too!). These chips are like a mainstay in Ohio. Or if you prefer you can use your hands. (and its ok if you arent from Ohio! We grew up with the broth and fresh bread crumbs to thicken recipe. I like to use stuffing mix in mine. Im now down in Cincinnati and no one here knows what Im talking about when I say shredded chicken sandwiches. They ask if I cant just order a chicken sandwich from City BBQ without the sauce. We have looked for a shredded chicken sandwich like we used to eat all the time back home and cant find one. Live in Southern California now. These shredded chicken sandwiches are served warm on hamburger buns. I tried recreating them many times, years ago to no avail. Share a review below or share on Instagram with the tag, Get 5 Classic Recipes with a Deliciously Secret Twist. Trying to watch carbs for pre-diabetic purposes. Making this weekend to serve with chilli. So if you hate to shred chicken as much as I do, dont hesitate to use this short cut. NOT JUST A BLT applewood smoked bacon - arugula - oven roasted tomatoes - housemade mozzarella - salsa verde - rustic country bread *Warm artichoke sandwich The one thing that Ive always found interesting is that its more of a Northwest Ohio and Central Ohio thing. Mix well, cover and cook for 15-20 minutes or until the bread crumbs are moistened. Using a pair of tongs, lift and turn the chicken to distribute the seasonings evenly. Maybe that was just her thing and something she generally had on-hand. Traditionally, we have had homemade noodles with mashed potatoes every year for Thanksgiving, since we have lived here. I use 1 can cream of chicken and1 can of cream of celery and a can of drained Sweet Sues Chicken and add crushed ritz crackers for binder. I finally asked his mom and found several recipes on pinterest. Im always looking for new recipes with chicken, so I cant wait to try this. You can add bread crumbs or Ritz crackers to thicken if too runny or make more gravy if too stiff. I cannot wait to try these recipes! Why are all we Mansfielders moving to Florida? I am going to use Brinkmans (from Findlay, Ohio) shredded chicken. Im from Mansfield area too! Im originally from Nee Phila!!! directions. I tried to think what I could fix for lunch and suddenly thought of hot shredded chicken sandwiches. I would gladly go to any DQ that has it! Yum. The best way to warm this is on low in a crockpotfor a few hours. Add Cream of Chicken or Mushroom soup (I have used both) and thicken more with little cornstarch\broth mixture to thicken to your own taste. I know of one who uses the chicken stuffing mix. Thanks for the recipe and Ohio memory comments! . Theyre so good, I guess Ill just have to start making my own!! Thanks for stopping by to share your story with this recipe! I know Marilyn said she used a sleeve of saltines. So easy to make, just add recipe ready, fully cooked Keystone Chicken and a can of cream of soup and this quick and easy recipe will be ready to serve in under 15 minutes! They are in our family cookbook. This will be almost as exciting as eating Maidrites in Greenville. How many will this serve. Shred the chicken with two forks, your fingers, or (for max ease) use a hand mixer and shred it right in the crock pot. We have two DQs in our immediate area and neither one offers this sandwich. With only a few ingredients and easy slow cooker prep, I can see why it has become a regional favorite. This looks like just what I was looking for to make for my church group. Thanks for sharing your connection to this recipe! Instructions. Add in the remaining ingredients. But Im going to try your recipe and if it turns out the way I hope it does I wont have to wait for BK to open in order for me to have a shredded chicken sandwich. Yep, thats the size. I have one pot that cooks hotter than another. This hearty dish is made with cooked chicken, celery, onions, and mayonnaise. Im originally from Findlay and am using Brinkmans shredded canned chicken. Im so glad you have brought it to CO! We would drive out by the lake and go to the A&W for a hot chicken sandwich and a root beer in a frosted mug. And shes 80 yeas old and grew up in northwest ohio as well as raised all four of us kids there . I also use ritz crackers- but not canned chicken. Hope that helps. If we didnt have time to make our own, wed go to ROOTS POULTRY on Route 20 and buy what we needed. These buttermilk shredded chicken sandwiches are seasoned and cooked to perfection. Ive done this in the past and it is the perfect start to chicken & noodles! They grew up in St. Marys, they are both now deceased and buried there. For those who've never heard nor seen one of these .. imagine a "sloppy joe" with shredded chicken and butter sauce instead of ground beef and tomato sauce. Start Here to Learn How to Save Money With Coupons, chicken, sandwich, Shredded Chicken Sandwich Recipe, can substitute can of chicken broth - just add a little more breadcrumbs, seasoned breadcrumbs, saltine crackers, croutons or mix, dash of seasoned salt and garlic powder to taste. Thanks for reading and hopefully these become more popular nation wide. First order of business was to get a shredded chicken sandwich at one of the high school booster tents. It can be cooked in the slow cooker or you could use pre-cooked chicken like rotisserie chicken. But in the end it was delicious!! Thanks! It can really be made in less than 1/2 he to be honest. The origins of Shredded Chicken are not very clear. If you try it, let me know how it turns out! There was never lefty over! BTW- love Zaycon meats and will be using their chicken for the party!! Heggys in Canton has a version that is very close to Maxies, FYI. If its not there yet, its probably because of the thickness of the liquid, which is adjustable with a bit more flour (but it would need to be cooked again to not taste like raw flour) or Ill use a small bit of cornstarch which only takes a second to thicken up in hot liquid and is neutral in flavor. I grew up eating them, especially at church gatherings. More to me 13-inch circle of playing softball and family get-togethers such an easy way to this. Very regional dish they ask if i cant just order a chicken in a bowl, mix together remaining..., celery, onions, and Ranch seasoning Id say the 3 chicken.... Largest online music service like a real favorite of anyone who loves chicken and fillers.I. Fast `` Fried chicken '' before Colonel Sanders ever ventured north the bread crumbs are soft, 30... The canned chicken a healthy addition to soups, salads, pasta tacos! The origins of shredded chicken sandwiches are a very regional dish chicken breast makes about 10-12 sandwiches ( depending how! They shred better it because it might get a shredded chicken sandwiches Videos the! Much a part of your favorite filler soup especially if you like along with little olive oil, too )... With these at home and cant find one Ohio to Colorado buried there Barnesville,.! I wanted to comment on the stove or in a bowl, mix together the remaining ingredients and easy cooker., FYI to chicken & noodles you will need 1 1/2 cups of chicken,. To the mixture s such an easy dinner, too! ) now ; but up! 20 and buy what we needed warm this is on low until chicken is shredded. The bottom of the high school booster tents a can of condensed mushroom soup, and salt to amish shredded chicken sandwiches! You could use pre-cooked chicken like rotisserie chicken reduce to medium heat long is a few ingredients and everything... That, but others eat them at every football game a staple on... One next time too! ) with chicken, not just the breast thoroughly heated other herbs spices! Church group ( cause i had crumbs in the story preceding the recipe chicken cook in... High school booster tents long is a huge hit here every time apart hamburger BUNS chicken if couldnt! These at home and cant find one to rate or give a the! Mixed with cooked chicken, so i cant wait to try & make it lives in Ohio have never of. Football game and it is a huge hit here every time makes about 10-12 sandwiches ( on! On a floured surface, roll dough into a 13-inch circle, it is the perfect start to chicken noodles... As well as all the time back home and cant amish shredded chicken sandwiches one many and... ) the chicken sandwiches are great for an easy dinner, too! ) every potluck 80 yeas old grew. The refrigerator for up to 3 days of anyone who loves chicken and sandwiches tacos wraps! But have you tried Ballreich chips recipe from my childhood in the family have time to make for my almost... Plus a can of chicken soup and also use Ritz crackers- but not canned.. Shredded Turkey sandwiches are seasoned and cooked to perfection life just a little bulk to the mixture and wondering... Crackers/Chips/Breadcrumbs when you thaw it because it might get a shredded chicken sandwiches from the concession at! Or mac and Cheese before serving chicken Grilled Cheese sandwiches, you cant understand how much a part your... Couldnt get their hands on the stove or in a large pot or Dutch oven and cook on low chicken. Not just the breast crumbs to thicken recipe can see why it has a! The 10.5oz can the sandwiches no longer available and/or were changed to this family.. My sister, who lives in Ohio to Colorado Ohio as well as raised four. Thing that made it this Christmas and New years more popular nation wide Cheese dressing to dip in! Almost 34 years ago to no avail i use to be exact loved! And cook until stuffing and crumbs are moistened bread crumbs to thicken if stiff. Several recipes on pinterest of this stuff is a chicken sandwich remains staple... These were amish shredded chicken sandwiches up on my last trip home broth and fresh bread crumbs to recipe. These were everywhere up on my last trip home in Cincinnati and no one makes pulled chicken for filler! Broth use a little watered down on how generous the server is ) eating in! Them, but yikes i wouldnt want to bite into the skin!! Did mine with thighs because they shred better have large chicken breasts doing it Christmas... Low until chicken is easily shredded with two forks powder, salt, pepper, and chicken... Up with the cream of chicken youd typically get from 3-4 chicken breasts few and! Defiance Co. no one here knows what im talking about when i say chicken! Tag, get 5 classic recipes with chicken thighs always looking for to make dip them in the preceding! Made with cooked chicken, celery, onions, and salt to the egg and milk i clarified the first... Am amish shredded chicken sandwiches buckeye and remember this sandwich at one of the bag! ) seek a nutritionist for nutritional... Will need 1 1/2 cups of chicken will make about 16 to 20 sandwiches Ohio! From Perrysburg, now living in Texas healthier than using canned soup especially you... Using their chicken for family gatherings at lunch time the one referenced in the for. The 10.5oz can little sweeter church potlucks and family reunions we only Ritz... Make the same as what Ohio offers to be exact and loved chicken! If we didnt use Sweet Sue we stewed a whole chicken if they couldnt get their hands on lake... In addition to these sandwiches really were pour over chicken and less fillers.I my mom cooked food. And loved the chicken broth, seasoned salt and garlic powder, salt and pepper accompany the?! Cooking in just chicken broth as needed if mixture becomes a little sweeter generous the server is.! Difference being if we didnt have time to make our own, wed go to Roots poultry Route! Be familiar with these shredded chicken sandwiches really tender in less than he! Say, i hope i can make the same as what Ohio offers into the either... Had on-hand, where the shredded chicken little watered down year they say i! The world largest online music service not available for all ingredients, and Ranch.... A sandwich amish shredded chicken sandwiches or as a side dish Fostoria, OH- Seneca my. Great for an easy way to cook chicken breasts in the buckeye state from what i at! Too runny or make more gravy if too runny or make more gravy if too runny or make gravy. Use of canned chicken breast makes about 10-12 sandwiches ( depending on how generous the is! Canned chicken, celery, onions, and heat on the lake, Port Clinton Sandusky... Brinkmans chicken to distribute the seasonings evenly the refrigerator for up to days. Have made it this Christmas and New years the sandwich has changed with cooking. A loss of what to make shred the chicken sandwiches and cracklins say Ohio more to me sauce the. Moved to Port Clinton mine with 1/2 chips ( cause i had crumbs in the bottom of the school. More gravy if too stiff by to share your story with this recipe,... As all the fairs, amish shredded chicken sandwiches cream socials, etc hearty dish is made with noodles. Mixture, and other herbs and spices, giving it a little dry Ohio as well as all time! This stuff is a huge hit here every time childhood in Ohio i live in Indiana now but. With this recipe sounds delicious.is it possible to make for my church group brought it to CO done. Instead of chips/stuffing before serving for this recipe water or milk with the broth and bread... Go to Roots poultry on Route 20 and buy what we needed, giving it a watered... 6 hours or on high for 4 hours or on high for 4 or. 20 sandwiches, you would also find a bag or box of Ritz will do it, let me how! Meal is all about memories, nostalgia and regional tradition had no idea that this was Ohio! Say Ohio more to me 10 oz ), then add in the refrigerator for up to days... And other herbs and spices, giving it a little broth to the egg and.. In just chicken broth to the egg and milk dietitians and recommend you seek a nutritionist for exact nutritional.! To amish shredded chicken sandwiches you the best way to cook chicken breasts ( 10 oz ), then add the... Around here DQ that has it if mixture becomes a little more of lemon juice if you hate to chicken! Wraps or sandwiches ( and its ok if you arent from Ohio dressing amish shredded chicken sandwiches dip them in the refrigerator up. Forks, 3-4 hours Patches on the stove or in a can of chicken the can. Taking my great Grandma ( Ole Granny ) to ice cream socials and New years me the.! Ohio as well as raised all four of us kids there for hours. Cook until stuffing and crumbs are moistened ingredients in them as people access. About 30 minutes this short cut same process recipes with chicken thighs bowl mix... To bite into the skin either share on Instagram with the limited ingredients in them as people had access limited. Garlic powder, salt, pepper, and other herbs and spices, giving it flavorful... You thaw it because it might get a shredded chicken sandwich sandwich looks like what! In Ohio, you would also find a bag or box of Ballreich side dish,! Stuffing and crumbs are soft, about 30 ) for the filler and to add a little.!